Meaning of the Treaty
The treaty itself is short consisting of only three articles. The first article grants the Queen of England governorship over New Zealand. The second article guarantees to the chiefs, their continued chieftainship, and ownership of their lands and treasures (taonga). It also specifies that maori will sell land only to the Crown. The third article guarantees to all Maori the same rights as all other British subjects. Unfortunately the English and Maori versions are not quite identical. This has caused difficulty in interpreting the treaty.
The most critical difference revolves around the interpretation of two maori words, kawanatanga (literally governorship) which is ceded to the queen in the first article, and rangatiratanga (literally chieftainship) which is retained by the chiefs in the second. Depending on how these words are interpreted the treaty can be anything from a ceding of absolute sovereignty to a simple management contract employing the queen to look after maori lands on their behalf.
Because of the short length and limited scope of the treaty it is not a suitable document to be a constitution. However it is the basis of New Zealand's founding myth and is a vitally important document because of this. Often people speak of the spirit of the treaty. Unfortunately there is no clear consensus as to the nature of this spirit. For some people the spirit is one of the joining of two peoples to become one, or as Hobson himself said on the day of the first signing, "Now we are one people". For others the spirit is one of a partnership between the Crown and Maori, a philosophy in New Zealand known as biculturalism.
Regardless of the political controversy which continues to swirl around the meaning of the treaty, it remains an extraordinary document when viewed in historical context of the time. The contrast between the treaty and the treatment accorded indigenous people by European colonisers in most other parts of the world is striking. While the path has been far from smooth (see the Maori Wars), most New Zealanders remain proud that their nation at least started with the best of intentions.
External links